- American Indian Law
- Business Disputes
- Creditors' Rights
- Executive Termination & Benefits
- False Claims Act
- Financial Services
- Food & Drug
- Health Care
- Intellectual Property
- Internal Investigations
- American Indian Law
- Congressional Investigations
- Criminal Defense
- Export Control
- False Claims Act
- Financial Services
- Food & Drug
- Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA)
- Health Care
- Intellectual Property
- Internal Investigations
Yale Law School, J.D., 1985
- Notes and Topics Editor, Yale Law and Policy Review
- Thomas I. Emerson Prize for Outstanding Legislative Services Project
Wichita State University, M.U.A., 1982
Wichita State University, B.A., 1980
D. Brian Hufford
D. Brian Hufford has developed a national practice representing patients and health care providers such as doctors, hospitals, and medical equipment companies in disputes with health insurance companies. He has experience in insurance and health care matters under Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and related federal and state laws, having led litigation that resulted in two of the largest recoveries ever obtained in health insurance class actions.
His work on litigation against United Healthcare led to a $350 million settlement, and in a similar action against Health Net, resulted in a $250 million settlement. Brian also served as co-lead counsel in other national health care litigation against United, Aetna, WellPoint, CIGNA, and Blue Cross and Blue Shield entities. Recently, Brian successfully argued health care appeals before the U.S. Courts of Appeal for the Second, Third and Fifth Circuits, and was lead counsel in two recent trials against Blue Cross and Blue Shield entities on behalf of providers and provider associations.
Brian has been recognized in industry rankings such as Benchmark Litigation and Super Lawyers. Brian also serves on the Editorial Advisory Board of BNA’s Health Law Reporter and is a member of the Kennedy Forum Legal Workgroup.
In addition to representing individual patients and health care providers, Brian has pursued claims for a number of significant institutions, including medical associations such as the American Medical Association (AMA), Medical Society of the State of New York, American Dental Association, American Chiropractic Association, Congress of Chiropractic State Associations, New York Chiropractic Council, and Pennsylvania Chiropractic Association. He has also represented a number of unions in health care actions on behalf of their members, including the New York State United Teachers, Civil Service Employees Association, New York State Police Investigators Association, and Organization of NYS Management Confidential Employees.
Brian has written and lectured extensively in the area of health care litigation. He has spoken at conferences and seminars sponsored by organizations such as the National Association of Attorneys General, American Medical Association, American Corporate Counsel Association, American Chiropractic Association, and Congress of Chiropractic State Associations, and the American Conference Institute for the National Forum on ERISA Litigation, among others.
Prior to entering private practice, Brian spent two years as an honors attorney in the U.S. Department of the Treasury’s Honors Law Program. Brian attended Yale Law School, where he was notes and topics editor for the Yale Law and Policy Review and was awarded the Thomas I. Emerson Prize for the Outstanding Legislative Services Project. He also holds a Bachelor of Arts and a Master of Urban Affairs from Wichita State University.
- Led the precedent-setting United Healthcare case, which settled on behalf of a nationwide class of providers and subscribers for $350 million in 2010, the largest settlement of an ERISA benefit class action in history. Retained by the American Medical Association and various other associations and individual plaintiffs, Brian challenged United’s use of a flawed database to determine usual, customary and reasonable (UCR) rates for out-of-network services. The case served as a catalyst for then-New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo’s investigation into the health insurance industry, leading to the creation of a new and independent database to provide UCR data. In an article in the New York Times on October 27, 2010 states that “a breakthrough came when lawyers for the attorney general’s office consulted” with Brian, leading to a “collaboration” between the Attorney General’s Office and Brian that “brought results.” In a similar action against Health Net, Brian obtained a certified class of ERISA-insured patients followed in 2008 by a settlement valued at $249 million.
- Argued before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit on behalf of the New York State Psychiatric Association and various individual mental healthcare providers and patients against United. In a precedent-setting decision, the Second Circuit confirmed in 2015 that United could be sued for benefits under ERISA and for violations of the Federal Parity Act, even with respect to self-funded plans, where United served solely as a claims administration. Amicus briefs were filed on behalf of Brian’s clients by the U.S. Department of Labor, American Medical Association, American Psychiatric Association and Patrick Kennedy (the original sponsor of the Federal Mental Health Parity Act as a U.S. Representative from Rhode Island).
- Argued before the Third Circuit on behalf of providers and plaintiffs in his own case and, as amici curiae, on behalf of the American Medical Association and the Medical Society of New Jersey in a related case, Accepting Brian’s argument, the Third Circuit issued a precedent-setting decision in 2015 confirming that providers who have been assigned the right to receive benefit payments from their ERISA-insured patients are legally entitled to assert legal claims under ERISA to challenge benefit denials.
- Pursued an appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit in an action against United on behalf of one of the nation’s largest surgical implant providers after the district court held that a provider’s state court claims against United were preempted by ERISA. Arguing the appeal before the appellate panel, Brian succeeded in reversing the decision by a 3-0 vote, based on the allegations that United made affirmative misrepresentations to the provider over whether it could bill and be paid directly by United for its services, which did not implicate the underlying purpose of ERISA. Thereafter, United sought en banc review, after which Brian persuaded the Department of Labor to file an amicus brief in support of its position, and to participate in oral argument. Brian successfully argued the appeal before the en banc panel, which unanimously found our client’s favor. United then filed a petition for writ of certiorari, which the U.S. Supreme Court denied on February 25, 2013, leaving the Fifth Circuit’s decision intact.
- Represented a durable medical equipment provider challenging repayment demands issued by Aetna for previously paid benefits as in violation of ERISA. The complaint brought on behalf of the client was initially dismissed by the district court, and Brian successfully reversed the decision before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit.
- Represented two health care providers who were sued for billing fraud. After successfully removing the case to federal court, with a finding that ERISA completely preempted the fraud claims, he was lead trial counsel in a 20-day ERISA bench trial. A complete judgment in favor of his clients was obtained, enjoining the insurer from seeking to recover previously paid benefits and ordering returning of improperly recouped funds, plus interest.
- Appointed Chair of the Plaintiffs’ Executive Committee in In re Aetna UCR Litigation by Judge Faith Hochberg, an MDL action challenging how Aetna paid for out-of-network health care services. In appointing Brian, Judge Hochberg specifically addressed his work in a prior healthcare litigation, stating: “The Court similarly appointed [Brian’s firm] to be Plaintiffs’ spokesman to the Court in the Health Net litigation because the Court found D. Brian Hufford, Esq. to be the attorney most capable of presenting Plaintiffs’ position in a clear and concise manner.”
- Represented chiropractors and state chiropractic associations challenging Aetna’s policy of making repayment demands and placing providers into prepayment review. He defeated Aetna’s motion to dismiss, upholding ERISA claims on behalf of the providers.
- Represented the American Chiropractic Association, the Congress of State Chiropractic Associations, various state associations, and individual providers in an action challenging UnitedHealth Group’s repayment demand policy and improper restrictions on coverage for chiropractic services. He defeated the defendant’s motion to dismiss, upholding ERISA claims on behalf of providers.
- Represented patients who were subjected to the imposition of improper length-of-stay guidelines for hospitalization. The defendant’s motion to dismiss was denied, and the decision was upheld on appeal by 5-0 vote.
- Represented insurance subscribers in action against Healthsource, Inc. for failing to disclose the financial incentives it paid to providers to encourage reductions in the level of care provided. He defeated the defendant’s motion to dismiss, and the court upheld his clients’ claims that the insurer had breached its fiduciary duties under ERISA.
- Representing individual patients and putative classes in actions against major insurance companies for their failure to cover an FDA-approved treatment for depression. The plaintiffs allege breaches of fiduciary duties and wrongful denial of benefits under ERISA.
- Representing a putative class of patients in an action against a major insurance company for allegedly discriminating against out-of-network psychiatrists and other mental health providers for mental health services. Plaintiffs allege that the insurer’s policy of reimbursing mental health providers less than non-mental health specialists for providing the same services violates ERISA.
- December 7, 2016
- October 20, 2016
- September 20, 2016
- June 22, 2016
- Zuckerman Spaeder Lawsuit Says Magellan and Blue Shield of CA Illegally Restrict Mental Health CoverageMay 27, 2016
- November 30, 2015
- Two Federal Court Decisions Support Zuckerman Spaeder’s Unique Use of ERISA on Behalf of Health ProvidersSeptember 21, 2015
- Zuckerman Spaeder LLP and Psych-Appeal, Inc. File Class Action Lawsuits Against Aetna and Cigna for Allegedly Denying Depression TreatmentSeptember 11, 2015
- After Four Years, Lawsuit against UnitedHealth Moves Forward; New Brief Sheds Light on Insurer’s Failure to Comply with ERISAAugust 31, 2015
- Ruling Against UnitedHealth Affirms ERISA’s Power to Hold Insurers Accountable; Strengthens Federal Mental Health Parity LawAugust 20, 2015
- Zuckerman Spaeder Brings Action in New York Against EmblemHealth for Denial of Mental Health Coverage; Says Insurer Fails to Comply with New York Mental Health Parity LawJune 22, 2015
- June 2, 2015
- July 8, 2014
- In Case Challenging Health Insurer Recoupment Practices, Judge Issues Permanent Injunction on Behalf of Zuckerman Spaeder LLP ClientJune 4, 2014
- Zuckerman Spaeder LLP Files Class Action Lawsuit Against Health Insurers Denying Mental Health CoverageMay 27, 2014
- Zuckerman Spaeder LLP Client Wins Precedent-Setting Trial Victory in Challenge to Health Insurer Recoupment PracticesMarch 31, 2014
- Health Insurance Litigators D. Brian Hufford and Jason S. Cowart Join Zuckerman Spaeder LLP’s New York OfficeJanuary 15, 2014
Mentioned & Quoted
- January 11, 2017Bloomberg BNAhttps://www.bna.com/healthcare-policy-fraud-n73014449681/
- December 5, 2016Law360
- October 19, 2016New Jersey Law Journalhttp://www.njlawjournal.com/id=1202770248968/Court-Approves-33M-Horizon-Deal-Including-11M-in-Fees?mcode=1202615653063&slreturn=20160919144400
- September 19, 2016Law360https://www.law360.com/articles/841911/unitedhealth-plan-holders-win-class-cert-in-erisa-suit
- June 21, 2016Law360http://www.law360.com/articles/809107/horizon-to-pay-chiropractors-33m-in-erisa-settlement?te_pk=625effa6-0717-437f-b7c4-be17f39a4805&utm_source=user-alerts&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=tracked-entity-alert
- February 18, 2016BNA's Health Law Reporterhttps://essential.bna.com/login/signin?msg=deny&url=http%3A%2F%2Fhealthlawrc.bna.com%2Fhlrc%2Fdisplay%2Flink_res.adp%3Flt%3Demail%26fname%3DA0H8Y9M2W0%26lf%3Deml%26emc%3Dhlln%3Ahlrc%3A113&lddty=-518&pcv=
- February 9, 2016Law360http://www.law360.com/articles/757245/mom-allowed-to-join-mental-health-erisa-suit-against-uhc
- January 22, 2016Law360http://www.law360.com/employment/articles/749757
- December 12, 2015Healthcare Executive Insighthttp://healthcare-executive-insight.advanceweb.com/News/Daily-News-Watch/Zuckerman-Spaeder-Names-Law360-MVP.aspx
- The MVPs of Health LawNovember 25, 2015Law360
- November 24, 2015Law360http://www.law360.com/articles/730997/health-mvp-zuckerman-spaeder-s-d-brian-hufford
- November 16, 2015Law360http://www.law360.com/newyork/articles/727235
- November 8, 2015Law360http://www.law360.com/securities/articles/723363
- August 11, 2014Healthcare Finance Newshttp://www.healthcarefinancenews.com/news/independence-blue-cross-clawback-case-new-precedent-sue-insurer?single-page=true
- August 6, 2014Crain's Chicagohttp://www.chicagobusiness.com/article/20140806/NEWS03/140809879/lawsuit-blue-cross-balks-at-residential-mental-health-coverage
- June 2, 2014Behavioral Healthcarehttp://www.behavioral.net/article/class-action-suit-against-unitedhealthcare-examines-how-parity-applied
- May 23, 2014Top Class Actionshttp://www.topclassactions.com/lawsuit-settlements/lawsuit-news/28153-unitedhealthcare-class-action-filed-mental-health-claim-denials/
- April 16, 2014Medical Practice Insiderhttp://www.medicalpracticeinsider.com/best-practices/how-get-your-practice-through-its-next-recoupment-unscathed
- Chiropractors Win ‘Unusual’ Insurance ProtectionsApril 2, 2014Reuters (via WestLaw)
- March 28, 2014Law360http://www.law360.com/employment/articles/523007/health-insurer-ordered-to-alter-payment-notice-process
- March 10, 2014National Law Journalhttp://www.nationallawjournal.com/id=1202646038122/A%20Long%20Struggle%20for%20Mental%20Health%20Parity?mcode=0&curindex=0&curpage=ALL&slreturn=20140214161140
- February 5, 2014New York Law Journalhttp://www.newyorklawjournal.com/this-weeks-news/id=1202641562952/Personal%20Notes%20on%20Lawyers?mcode=1202615038803&curindex=19
- Career Tracker: Lawyers on the MoveJanuary 17, 2014Reuters
- January 17, 2014Law360http://www.law360.com/articles/501871/zuckerman-spaeder-nabs-pomerantz-health-pros-in-ny
- Medical Provider Litigation: Standing by Healthcare Providers to Sue, Patient Assignment of Rights and MoreAmerican Conference Institute’s 12th National Forum on ERISAJune 27, 2016
The Omni San Francisco Hotel
San Francisco, CA
- National Summer meeting of the National Association of Attorneys GeneralJune 23, 2016
- Mental Health Parity PanelTestimony before the Behavioral Health Subcommittee of the Legislative Health and Human Services Committee of the State of New Mexico LegislatureOctober 8, 2014
- December 1, 2014New York Law Journal
- March 10, 2014The National Law Journal
- Managed Care Litigation: The Role of ProvidersNovember 2000Practising Law Institute
- Deterring Fraud vs. Avoiding the Strike Suit: Reaching An Appropriate BalanceSummer 1995Brooklyn Law Review
- New York
- U.S. Supreme Court
- U.S. Court of Appeals, Second Circuit
- U.S. Court of Appeals, Third Circuit
- U.S. Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit
- U.S. Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit
- U.S. Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
- U.S. District Court, District of Colorado
- U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York
- U.S. District Court, Southern District of New York